Being Heumann Review: A Mixed Take on Disability Rights Drama
A review of ‘Being Heumann’, a biopic starring Ruth Madeley as activist Judith Heumann, explores both its strengths and shortcomings.
Mixed Reactions to ‘Being Heumann’ at Toronto Film Festival
The Toronto Film Festival recently showcased a new biopic, ‘Being Heumann’, focused on the influential disability rights activist, Judith Heumann. Directed by Sian Heder, known for ‘Coda’, the film casts Ruth Madeley in the lead role. With its ambitious attempt to capture the essence of Heumann’s activism, the film manages to both shine and stumble.
‘Being Heumann’ attempts to highlight the groundbreaking efforts of Judith Heumann, a key figure in disability advocacy from the 1970s until her death in 2023. These efforts played a crucial role in making public spaces accessible across the United States. However, despite its heartfelt intentions, the film struggles to maintain a consistent tone throughout.
Interesting Start, Uneven Execution
Initially, the movie draws in audiences with a vibrant depiction of Heumann’s activism, particularly illustrating the 1977 sit-in at the San Francisco office of the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare. This historic protest is a pivotal moment, demonstrating Heumann’s strategic efforts in garnering support and pressuring government officials. The film effectively captures the energy of this era, echoing the spirit of the 1970s’ activism with a genuine portrayal of the period.
However, as the plot progresses, ‘Being Heumann’ seems to lose some of its initial zest. While Heder’s film strives to balance fact with drama, the latter half of the film turns somewhat predictable. The biopic, despite its strong start, gradually transitions into a routine historical narrative, failing to maintain the dynamic rebelliousness of Heumann’s real-life movement.
A Worthwhile Watch with Room for Growth
Ruth Madeley delivers a notable performance as Judith Heumann, convincingly adopting a Brooklyn accent to embody the activist’s gritty determination. Yet, despite Madeley’s commendable depiction, the film’s narrative struggles to match the impact of its protagonist’s legacy.
Overall, ‘Being Heumann’ is noteworthy for its attempt to depict a little-known chapter in disability rights history. It provides an important depiction of Heumann’s impact but could benefit from a bolder, more cohesive delivery. The film contributes to ongoing conversations about representation and accessibility in media, despite its mixed storytelling approach.
Photo by Anton Kotlovskii on Unsplash
